The morning after his bandmates carried him offstage in a wheelchair, Joe Bonsall made a phone call that would change the future of The Oak Ridge Boys. He wasn’t calling to say goodbye. He was calling the young man who would take his place. It was the final night of their 2023 Christmas tour. Joe was battling ALS, a devastating illness he had kept largely private. Despite his weakening body, he had promised to finish every Christmas show. He kept that promise, singing from a stool while his voice remained strong through the final note. As his bandmates helped him into his wheelchair, Joe quietly told them, “I’m done. I’ll call tomorrow.” The others had already offered to retire the group rather than continue without him. But Joe couldn’t bear the thought of the music ending because he could no longer stand beside them. The next morning, he called Ben James, a 27-year-old bluegrass singer whose talent he had recognized years earlier. Joe had once handed Ben his microphone during “Elvira,” giving the young man a moment in the spotlight. Now he was offering him something far greater. “I’m done,” Joe told him. “The position is yours. Put your singing britches on.” On December 30, Ben stepped into Joe’s place onstage. A few days later, Joe shared a message with the fans who had loved him for decades, asking them to give Ben the same warmth and encouragement they had always given him. Joe knew he would never sing those songs with his brothers again. But instead of asking them to stop, he made sure another voice would be there when the music started. He couldn’t stay onstage. So he gave someone else the chance to carry on.
On December 17, 2023, The Oak Ridge Boys played a Christmas show at the Egyptian Theatre in DeKalb, Illinois. It was the last date of their holiday run, and it…