THEY WEREN’T ACTUALLY SISTERS, AND ONLY ONE SURVIVED TO HEAR THEIR SONG HIT NUMBER ONE.Betty Jack Davis and Mary Frances Penick met at a Kentucky high school in 1947. Betty gave her friend the nickname “Skeeter,” and Mary Frances took Betty’s surname when they hit the road together. They sang through lunch breaks, ground out radio shows in Cincinnati and Detroit, and finally caught the ear of RCA producer Steve Sholes.On May 23, 1953, they cut “I Forgot More Than You’ll Ever Know” with a stellar Nashville crew, including Chet Atkins. The record started moving. But they wouldn’t be around to watch it climb.On August 1, after a late-night radio gig in Wheeling, West Virginia, they piled into a car heading home to Kentucky. Near Cincinnati the next morning, a drowsy driver crossed the center line and hit them head-on. Betty Jack was killed instantly. Skeeter was left severely injured. Early newspaper reports mistakenly claimed both singers had gone.While Skeeter fought for her life in a hospital bed, the single went straight to No. 1, parked there for eight weeks, and even cracked the pop Top 20. Betty Jack never heard what their masterpiece became.Recovery brought its own heavy shadows. Skeeter healed at the home of Betty Jack’s mother, Ollie, who kept her heavily medicated, played their old records on a loop, and pressured her to replace Betty Jack with her younger sister, Georgia. Worn down, Skeeter agreed. Six months after the wreck, she was back on stage beside a voice that shared the family blood, but could never replace the friend who built the harmony with her.The new duo cut nine singles and toured the country, but the magic of the original pairing was gone. They split in 1956. Skeeter walked away briefly before returning alone, eventually blowing past the tragedy with her 1962 global mega-hit, “The End of the World.”She conquered the charts on her own terms. But she never went back to the name she was born with. Mary Frances Penick lived out her life as Skeeter Davis—carrying the nickname and the surname given to her by the girl who once stood close enough to share every single note.
THE DAVIS SISTERS RECORDED THE SONG THAT WOULD MAKE THEM STARS. TEN WEEKS LATER, BETTY JACK WAS DEAD — AND SKEETER HAD TO HEAR THEIR NO. 1 RECORD WITHOUT HER.…