The Water Is Wide – Karla Bonoff

Karla Bonoff’s “The Water Is Wide” isn’t your typical folk song. While rooted in a centuries-old tradition, Bonoff’s rendition takes this classic ballad and imbues it with a poignant intimacy that resonates with contemporary listeners.

The song’s origins are shrouded in time, with variations appearing across various cultures. “The Water Is Wide” is a modal piece, meaning it utilizes a unique scale that creates a sense of ancient mystery. However, Bonoff’s arrangement departs from the traditional boisterous pub singalong style, opting for a more introspective and melancholic approach.

Bonoff’s gentle vocals and sparse accompaniment, often just a fingerpicked guitar, draw the listener into the emotional core of the song. The lyrics themselves are open to interpretation, but they generally deal with themes of loss, separation, and the search for meaning. Lines like “I am goin’ over Jordan” and “There is a better home a waitin’ for me” hint at a spiritual journey, perhaps a metaphor for navigating life’s challenges.

Bonoff’s “The Water Is Wide” stands out for its emotional vulnerability. Unlike some folk ballads that tell a story, this song invites the listener to participate in the emotional journey. The repetition of the title phrase, “The water is wide,” creates a sense of longing and uncertainty. Is the water a physical barrier, a symbol of emotional turmoil, or both? The song leaves room for contemplation.

Karla Bonoff’s “The Water Is Wide” isn’t just a beautiful rendition of a folk classic; it’s a testament to the power of music to evoke a range of emotions. The song’s simplicity and emotional honesty have made it a staple of Bonoff’s live performances, often serving as a poignant closing number. Whether you’re a seasoned folk enthusiast or a newcomer to the genre, Bonoff’s “The Water Is Wide” offers a timeless exploration of human emotions that continues to resonate with listeners today.