On the night of November 10, 2003, more than two thousand people filed into the Ryman Auditorium in Nashville. They had come for Johnny Cash. Tickets were free, given out by lottery, and cameras were set up so the evening could be shown later on television. The  country music world had already lost Johnny Cash two months earlier, on September 12, 2003. This was the night the public would get to say goodbye.

Many people expected a famous singer, a preacher, or a long speech to come first. The first voice that night was Rosanne Cash’s.

A Private Goodbye, Then a Public One

The family had already held a private funeral on September 15 at First Baptist Church in Hendersonville, Tennessee. Emmylou Harris and Sheryl Crow sang there, but they sang a gospel hymn and a Bob Dylan song. None of Johnny Cash’s own songs were reported at that service.

The Ryman memorial was different. It was open to the public, and it was built around his music. Before the night was over, his songs would come from stars of country and rock. But the first one came from his own family.

The Building That Held the Story

The Ryman was not a random choice of stage. For years it was home to the Grand Ole Opry. On July 7, 1956, a young Johnny Cash made his Opry debut there. That same night, backstage, he crossed paths with June Carter for the first time. Their love story started in that building, and twelve years later they married.

In May 2003 June Carter Cash passed away, and that September Johnny Cash followed her. So when the lights came up at the Ryman that November, the couple who had first met behind that stage were both gone.

Rosanne Cash Steps Forward

Rosanne Cash knew her father’s music from the inside. After she finished high school she went on the road with him. She started out helping with wardrobe and later sang backing vocals on his shows. She went on to build her own career and score her own hits.

That night she didn’t open with any of her own hits. She opened with one of his.

The Song: “I Still Miss Someone”

Johnny Cash wrote “I Still Miss Someone” with his nephew, Roy Cash Jr., and recorded it for Columbia Records in the summer of 1958 with producer Don Law. It was never sent out as the main single. It ended up on the B-side of “Don’t Take Your Guns to Town”, a story song about a young cowboy who ignores his mother’s warning.

The B-side lasted. It also appeared on The Fabulous Johnny Cash, and he kept singing it on stage for decades, including at his famous 1968 show at Folsom Prison. It became one of the songs fans expected to hear whenever he played live.

The song is simple and quiet. A man watches the season turn cold while couples walk past him. He tries to lose himself at a party, but his mind keeps going back to the woman who left. He sees her eyes wherever he looks and remembers being held by her. He wonders whether she regrets walking away. He tells himself love is waiting for him somewhere, yet he can’t let the old one go.

He recorded it just two summers after first meeting June backstage at the Ryman. Forty-five years later, his daughter sang it in that same building after both of them were gone.

What the Song Became That Night

Johnny Cash wrote it in 1958 as a song about lost love, and it is not about June. Neither the family nor Rosanne Cash has said publicly why it was picked to open the memorial. Still, it is hard to picture a better fit. A song about missing one person filled a room of two thousand people who were all missing the same man.

One reviewer who was at the Ryman wrote that Rosanne Cash sang it slowly and that her performance carried much of what everyone there was feeling. The song runs about two and a half minutes, and for that short stretch it carried the whole room’s goodbye.

The Circle Closes

After Rosanne Cash’s opening, other artists followed with Johnny Cash’s songs, one by one. To end the night, the whole Cash family joined the audience to sing “We’ll Meet Again.”

The song that opened the evening had once been a B-side most people flipped past. That night it was the first thing people heard at his memorial, sung by his daughter in the building where his love story with June began.

What song would you want played to say goodbye to you?

You Missed