The Untold Story of the Scene That Made Burt Reynolds Weep: Dolly Parton’s “I Will Always Love You”
There are moments in film that transcend the screen, etching themselves into the collective memory of a generation. One such moment happened in a smoky, dimly lit barroom in The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas. When Dolly Parton, as the world-weary madam Miss Mona, locked eyes with Burt Reynolds’ Sheriff Ed Earl Dodd and sang “I Will Always Love You,” it wasn’t just a scene; it was a cultural earthquake. This raw, heart-wrenching performance became so legendary that it knocked E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial from the top of the box office and forever altered the landscape of country music. This is the story behind the performance that laid a nation’s heart bare.
For many, “I Will Always Love You” is synonymous with Whitney Houston’s powerhouse version. But the version Dolly delivered in the film was its polar opposite—a fragile, stripped-down confession. Seated at a dusty piano, not as a superstar but as her character, every quaver in Dolly’s voice felt like a fragment of Miss Mona’s breaking heart. The stunned, tearful look on Burt Reynolds’ face was no act. Crew members on set later confirmed that Reynolds was genuinely overwhelmed, openly weeping through multiple takes, completely captivated by the raw emotion pouring from his co-star.
To truly grasp the power of this moment, you have to witness it. It’s a masterclass in vulnerability.
The scene ignited a firestorm across America. Its impact was immediate and profound. Movie theaters reported audiences demanding the scene be replayed, with fans lining up just to experience “the Dolly-Burt moment” again. It became a cultural talking point, debated by pastors from the pulpit for its “sinful” setting while simultaneously being used by marriage counselors as a perfect example of profound, selfless love. Critics hailed it as “the most vulnerable performance in musical history,” a powerful testament that a story set in a brothel could portray a love more pure and poignant than countless conventional Hollywood romances.
What audiences didn’t know was that the real drama was unfolding behind the scenes. Dolly had to fight fiercely to protect the integrity of her performance. Rare behind-the-scenes footage reveals her struggle with director Colin Higgins, who envisioned a more polished, orchestrated number. She rejected a staggering 17 different pre-recorded versions. Finally, she convinced him to let her do it her way: live, with just her and the piano, in a single, uninterrupted take. They filmed it at 4 AM as the sun began to rise, capturing a magic that could never be rehearsed.
This look behind the curtain shows the tension and the magic of its creation.
The emotional weight of the scene profoundly affected its stars. In journal entries later revealed in a documentary, Burt Reynolds confessed that the experience nearly made him quit acting altogether. “Dolly cracked me open like an egg,” he wrote, admitting he had never felt so exposed on camera. The footage of their rehearsals is electric, showing an intense connection. The story becomes even more poignant with the revelation that Dolly altered the song’s lyrics at the last minute, channeling her own real, unrequited feelings for Reynolds, who was secretly married at the time of filming. The heartbreak in her voice was devastatingly real.
Decades later, the scene’s legacy endures. Every year on July 23rd, the film’s release date, #WhorehouseLove trends as fans celebrate and recreate the iconic moment. The “Dolly Challenge” on TikTok has inspired over 1.2 million videos of people singing the song to their own crushes in bars, a testament to its timeless, universal appeal. Perhaps the most heartbreaking part of the legend is Dolly’s steadfast silence on the matter. To this day, she politely refuses to elaborate on the personal pain that fueled that once-in-a-lifetime performance. In her own words to reporters, “Some heartaches are too sacred to share.” The mystery, and the magic, live on.
Explore more of the genius behind the legend with some of her greatest hits.